The Bitcoin Whales: 1,000 People Who Own 40 Percent of the Market (Bitcoin Bubble?)

ILLUSTRATION: PATRIK MOLLWING FOR BLOOMBERG BUSINESSWEEK

On Nov. 12, someone moved almost 25,000 bitcoins, worth about $159 million at the time, to an online exchange. The news soon rippled through online forums, with bitcoin traders arguing about whether it meant the owner was about to sell the digital currency.

Holders of large amounts of bitcoin are often known as whales. And they’re becoming a worry for investors. They can send prices plummeting by selling even a portion of their holdings. And those sales are more probable now that the cryptocurrency is up nearly twelvefold from the beginning of the year.
 
About 40 percent of bitcoin is held by perhaps 1,000 users; at current prices, each may want to sell about half of his or her holdings, says Aaron Brown, former managing director and head of financial markets research at AQR Capital Management. (Brown is a contributor to the Bloomberg Prophets online column.) What’s more, the whales can coordinate their moves or preview them to a select few. Many of the large owners have known one another for years and stuck by bitcoin through the early days when it was derided, and they can potentially band together to tank or prop up the market.
 

“I think there are a few hundred guys,” says Kyle Samani, managing partner at Multicoin Capital. “They all probably can call each other, and they probably have.” One reason to think so: At least some kinds of information sharing are legal, says Gary Ross, a securities lawyer at Ross & Shulga. Because bitcoin is a digital currency and not a security, he says, there’s no prohibition against a trade in which a group agrees to buy enough to push the price up and then cashes out in minutes.

Regulators have been slow to catch up with cryptocurrency trading, so many of the rules are still murky. If traders not only pushed the price up but also went online to spread rumors, that might count as fraud. Bittrex, a digital currency exchange, recently wrote to its users warning that their accounts could be suspended if they banded together into “pump groups” aimed at manipulating prices. The law might also be different for other digital coins. Depending on the details of how they are structured and how investors expect to make money from them, some may count as currencies, according to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.

Asked about whether large holders could move in concert, Roger Ver, a well-known early bitcoin investor, said in an email: “I suspect that is likely true, and people should be able to do whatever they want with their own money. I’ve personally never had time for things like that though.”

“As in any asset class, large individual holders and large institutional holders can and do collude to manipulate price,” Ari Paul, co-founder of BlockTower Capital and a former portfolio manager of the University of Chicago endowment, wrote in an electronic message. “In cryptocurrency, such manipulation is extreme because of the youth of these markets and the speculative nature of the assets.”

The recent rise in its price is difficult to explain because bitcoin has no intrinsic value. Launched in 2009 with a white paper written under a pseudonym, it’s a form of digital payment maintained by an independent network of computers on the internet‚ using cryptography to verify transactions. Its most fervent believers say it could displace banks and even traditional money, but it’s only worth what someone will trade for it, making it prey to big shifts in sentiment.

Like most hedge fund managers specializing in cryptocurrencies, Samani constantly tracks trading activity of addresses known to belong to the biggest investors in the coins he holds. (Although bitcoin transactions are designed to be anonymous, each one is associated with a coded address that can be seen by anyone.) When he sees activity, Samani immediately calls the likely sellers and can often get information on motivations behind their sales and their trading plans, he says. Some funds end up buying one another’s holdings directly, without going into the open market, to avoid affecting the currency’s price. “Investors are generally more forthcoming with other investors,” Samani says. “We all kind of know who one another are, and we all help each other out and share notes. We all just want to make money.” Ross says gathering intelligence is legal.

Ordinary investors, of course, don’t have the cachet required to get a multimillionaire to take their call. While they can track addresses with large holdings online and start heated discussions of market moves on Reddit forums, they’re ultimately in the dark on the whales’ plans and motives. “There’s no transparency to speak of in this market,” says Martin Mushkin, a lawyer who focuses on bitcoin. “In the securities business, everything that’s material has to be disclosed. In the virtual currency world, it’s very difficult to figure out what’s going on.”

Ordinary investors are at an even greater disadvantage in smaller digital currencies and tokens. Among the coins people invest in, bitcoin has the least concentrated ownership, says Spencer Bogart, managing director and head of research at Blockchain Capital. The top 100 bitcoin addresses control 17.3 percent of all the issued currency, according to Alex Sunnarborg, co-founder of crypto hedge fund Tetras Capital. With ether, a rival to bitcoin, the top 100 addresses control 40 percent of the supply, and with coins such as Gnosis, Qtum, and Storj, top holders control more than 90 percent. Many large owners are part of the teams running these projects.

Some argue this is no different than what happens in more established markets. “A good comparison is to early stage equity,” BlockTower’s Paul wrote. “Similar to those equity deals, often the founders and a handful of investors will own the majority of the asset.” Other investors say the whales won’t dump their holdings, because they have faith in the long-term potential of the coins. “I believe that it’s common sense that these whales that own so much bitcoin and bitcoin cash, they don’t want to destroy either one,” says Sebastian Kinsman, who lives in Prague and trades coins. But as prices go through the roof, that calculation might change. 

BOTTOM LINE – It’s not necessarily illegal for big holders of some cryptocurrencies to discuss trading with one another. That puts small buyers at a disadvantage.

Bitcoin actually broke through the 17,000 barrier yesterday before retreating and is now back to 14,500 area.
bitcoinwilderide
Bitcoin has no intrinsic value? And that makes it different than the US Dollar, how?
Here is the Elizabeth Warren commemorative $5 Dollar bill.
indian-five-dollar-bill
Advertisements

Trumpcoin? Bitcoin Reaches $15,600 Mark (Up From $710 On 2016 Election Day of Trump)

Crypto-currency  Bitcoin has experienced a tremendous run-up since the 2016 election (November 8th) of Donald Trump. In fact, it has risen from $710 on election day 2016 to $15,600 as of today.

trumpcoin

The US Treasury 10 year yield rose dramatically on election day 2016, but today’s 10-year yield is about the same as it was in late November 2016.

The US Treasury 10Y-2Y curve continues to flatten as Trump enthusiasm waines as Democrats ferociously attempt to block almost any change proposed by Trump or Republicans.

trump102

Oddly, Bitcoin was left off the list off the Financial Systems Vulnerabilities Monitor.

db710a1c-411e-4040-8b88-654c5013a4a1-original

Robot Monster! Transportation Stocks, Bitcoin Zoom, Tech Stocks Stutter and Hindenburg Omen Keeps Flashing

Another day in the land of Central Bank bubbles.

According to Bloomberg, transportation stocks have rallied more than 8 percent in a week, realigning them with industrials at new highs in a coupling that is one of the market’s oldest bullish technical indicators. According to the century-old Dow Theory, simultaneous records in the groups trigger a buy signal for U.S. stocks. Optimism that changes in U.S. tax policy will benefit the industry reignited the Dow Jones Transportation Average on Monday, pushing it back to an all-time high along with the industrials gauge.

dowth

But at the same time, the Hindenburg Omen keeps … omening?

hindyomen

The tech stock index SOX is stuttering.

soxindex

And crypto-currency Bitcoin keeps bubbling.

bitgolddol

Yes, another day in the land of Central Bank-generated asset bubbles.

“There is no escape from us, fool humans. There is no escape!”

Janet Yellen and The FOMC creating asset bubbles. Here is a video of her last speech to Congress.

yellenrobot

 

 

 

Fed Chair Janet Yellen Urges Congress to Monitor U.S. Debt As She Steps Down (NOW A Warning??)

Federal Reserve Chair Janet Yellen’s final speech to Congress (Joint Economic Commitee)  reminded me of the scene in the movie Death Becomes Her where Meryl Streep swallows a magic potion and  Isabella Rosselini then says “Now a warning.”

Yes, Yellen warned Congress that they should monitor the US debt load, now at $20.6 trillion, up from $9.5 trillion in Q2 2008.  She also called on Congress to adopt policies that will promote investment, education and infrastructure spending.

Yes, US public debt outstanding has more than doubled since Team Bernanke/Yellen began quantitative easing (QE) back in September 2008.

pubdebtfed

Of course, The Fed buying US Treasuries helped fuel the enormous growth in US debt leaving The Federal Reserve as the largest owner (by far) of US Treasury debt.

sovdebtownership

Why didn’t Yellen mention declining M2 Money Velocity (GDP/M2 Money Stock)?

m2vfedpol

And why didn’t Yellen mention that The Fed killed-off Treasury volatility?

t10volfed

Notice that Yellen issued this warning as she is being replaced as Fed Chair and a new President (Trump).

Why did Yellen wait until her last speech to issue a warning that most economists already knew? 

At least Yellen didn’t say “Bottom’s up!”

f8d40c3315e554925616404f0bfbfe64--death-becomes-her-meryl-streep

Bitcoin Bursts To 11,500 Then Back To 9,500 As Consumer Purchasing Power Continues To Weaken

Are crypo-currencies like Bitcoin the new gold … or potential de-facto US currency? OR is Bitcoin and related crypto-currencies (e.g., Ethereum) in an appalling bubble? That is, few actual investors driving the price over 11,000. Time will tell.

But what we do know is that Bitcoin has just breached the $11,000 barrier while consumer purchasing power of the US Dollar keeps declining.

bitcoinvdollar

Ethereum is showing a similar meteoric rise.

ethereumclassic.png

UPDATE: Like any bubble,  Bitcoin and Ethereum Classic have lost a little air after 9am highs.

bitbiuibbbs

 

Of course, the creation of The Federal Reserve System in 1913 under President Woodrow Wilson helped to constantly devalue the US Dollar ever since.

ppfed.png

With the Franklin Roosevelt’s Executive Order of 1933 preventing the hoarding of gold (and the subsequent Richard Nixon unilateral cancellation of the direct international convertibility of the United States dollar to gold) …

PF-gold-confiscati_2525827b

we haven’t had to listen to fiery speeches like William Jennings Bryan on July 9, 1896, at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago. The issue was whether to endorse the free coinage of silver at a ratio of silver to gold of 16 to 1.

cofgold.jpg

The way it was in the United States.

US_Gold_Certificate-1

Hey, now we have FIAT currency (not backed by any precious commodity like gold or silver).

Yellen-on-the-50-dollar-bill-cartoon (1)

 

Digital Gold? Bitcoin Rebounds From Correction While US Dollar Weakens

Yes, the US Dollar is FIAT currency (not backed by a precious commodity like gold, silver or even iron pyrite).

Bitcoin, the largest crypto-currency, has more than recoverd from the “correction” last week. It has resumed its all-time high price This is happening as the US Dollar weakens.

bitgreen

Here is Bitcoin relative to Gold. Check out their relative performance since September.

bitgold

Is it digital gold? Well, Bitcoin is an alternative to FIAT currency like the US greenback, the Euro and the Yen. The massive expansion of Central Bank balance sheets has certainly concerned investors.

dlcb

An example of an 1899 $5 silver certificate.

lizwarren5sil